Rum Punches, Starfish and a Pirate Ship in Bocas del Toro, Panama

Four-photo collage showing a water-taxi ride, the Bocas Town waterfront, a woman aboard a pirate ship and a palm-lined beach in Bocas del Toro, Panama.

From my first water taxi into Bocas Town to sailing on a pirate ship and finding the Caribbean beaches I had imagined—Bocas del Toro was never boring.

Flagging Down a Shuttle to Bocas del Toro

After two nights hidden in the mountains at Lost and Found Jungle Hostel, I was ready to return to the heat.

I had enjoyed the quiet cloud forest, the treasure hunt and the incredible views, but Bocas del Toro was what I had really been looking forward to: tropical Caribbean islands, white-sand beaches and water warm enough that I would actually swim in it.

First, I had to get there.

Lost and Found wasn’t beside a bus terminal—or anything else, really. After hiking back down the mountain with my big backpack, I reached the highway and waited beside the road for transportation heading toward Bocas del Toro.

There was no departure board or reliable schedule to follow. The system was simple: stand beside the highway, watch for an approaching shuttle and wave it down.

So that is what I did.

And continued doing.

If my memory is correct, I waited close to an hour before one finally stopped for me. I had to trust that something would eventually appear.

Thankfully, it did.

The shuttle carried me through the mountains toward the Caribbean coast and dropped me near the mainland dock. From there, I boarded a water taxi for the final part of the journey to Bocas Town on Isla Colón.

After travelling through Panama by buses, shuttles and the occasional questionable roadside connection, arriving somewhere by boat felt like an appropriate entrance to the Caribbean.

Once I reached Bocas Town, I collected my backpack and walked to Bambuda Bocas Town. The hostel wasn’t located in the main backpacker area, and part of the property was under construction during my visit. Neither detail bothered me. I hadn’t come to Bocas del Toro to spend my days inside a hostel.

I had beaches to find.

My four-bed dorm felt comfortable and cosy, and—most importantly—the beds had curtains. After months in shared rooms, a curtain around a dorm bed felt like a tiny luxury. I dropped off my backpack, claimed my space and headed out to see the Caribbean beach I had been imagining.

The closest option was Playa Istmito.

Unfortunately, it wasn’t quite the tropical paradise I had pictured.

It was a beach, and it was beside the Caribbean Sea, but it didn’t resemble the white sand, clear water and palm-tree-lined scenery that had made me so excited to visit. Apparently, all those beautiful photographs had been taken somewhere else.

My first afternoon in Bocas ended with me feeling slightly disappointed. I had expected to walk out of my hostel and immediately find paradise.

I hadn’t found it yet.

Luckily, I had discovered something that promised to make up for the underwhelming first beach: a Saturday party aboard a pirate ship called the Black Magic.

I was 100% doing that.

Wide sandy shoreline and calm water at Playa Istmito near Bocas Town, Panama.

Playa Istmito was the first beach I visited in Bocas del Toro. It wasn’t the tropical Caribbean paradise I had pictured—but thankfully, Bocas had much better beaches waiting for me.

Day Drinking on the Black Magic Pirate Ship

The Black Magic wasn’t simply a boat with a pirate flag attached to it. It was a proper pirate ship, complete with costumed crew members, music, rum and an afternoon of sailing around Bocas del Toro.

Basically, I had been born for this.

I bought my ticket online for what I remember being approximately $35 USD. The confirmation was sent by email, which normally wouldn’t have been a problem. However, I was still travelling without the phone I had lost in Santa Catalina, and I had forgotten to save or screenshot the ticket while I had Wi-Fi.

I wasn’t completely without technology. I still had my ancient iPod Touch—the emergency Apple product I carried around from the technological dark ages. It could connect to Wi-Fi, access my email and take a few photos, but it wasn’t particularly useful without an internet connection.

Do not follow my example. Save your ticket offline before leaving your hostel.

On the afternoon of the cruise, I walked to the dock and paid around $2 USD for a water taxi to the Black Magic. I arrived early because I wanted to spend as much time aboard the ship as possible. I hadn’t travelled all the way to Bocas del Toro to be casually late for a pirate party.

Everything was going smoothly until someone asked to see my ticket.

I opened my email on the iPod Touch and couldn’t find it.

While everyone else was ready to board, I stood there scrolling through my inbox and holding up the line. Thankfully, the pirate ship had Wi-Fi. After a frantic search, I eventually found the confirmation hiding in my junk folder.

Apparently, even my email thought a ticket for an afternoon of drinking rum aboard a pirate ship sounded suspicious.

Once aboard, I set aside a drinking budget and prepared to make responsible financial decisions with it.

Rum punches cost around $4 USD each, which I thought was remarkably reasonable for a drink served on a pirate ship in the Caribbean. I don’t remember food being included or available to purchase, but I wasn’t particularly concerned about lunch at that moment.

I had rum.

Black Magic pirate ship docked beneath a blue sky in Bocas del Toro, Panama.

I had rum, a pirate ship and an entire afternoon ahead of me. What could possibly go wrong?

As the Black Magic sailed away from Bocas Town, I began talking to the other travellers aboard. Many had attended Filthy Friday, an island-hopping bar crawl held the previous day, and were still recovering from it.

I was slightly disappointed that I hadn’t known about Filthy Friday in time to join them. Then again, going on a bar crawl the night before spending an afternoon drinking on a pirate ship might have tested even my enthusiasm for partying.

The drinks kept appearing as we sailed around the islands. After a few hours, the ship anchored and everyone was invited to swim.

Naturally, I had already made friends by then. Travelling alone has never prevented me from meeting people, especially when rum punches and a pirate ship are involved. Someone suggested jumping from the ship into the water.

My initial response was sensible.

“I’m good.”

However, sensible decisions have a limited lifespan after several rum punches and a little encouragement. It probably didn’t take much persuasion before I changed my mind, climbed to the edge and jumped from a pirate ship into the Caribbean Sea.

It was exactly as much fun as it sounds.

Once everyone was back aboard, we began sailing toward Bocas Town—and that was when the real party started.

The music became louder, people began dancing and, unsurprisingly, my booty went directly to the dance floor. I was having the kind of glorious day that only comes from combining sunshine, the Caribbean, new friends and an irresponsible quantity of rum punch.

In my increasingly cheerful condition, I also convinced members of the crew to take ridiculous photos with me in their pirate costumes.

As the Black Magic sailed home, we watched the sun set over the water. It was everything I had hoped Bocas del Toro would be: warm, tropical, social and slightly chaotic.

We returned to the bay shortly after nightfall. The water taxi that had cost around $2 on the way there suddenly cost approximately $5 for the return trip.

What a rip-off.

Some of the people I had met planned to get food and continue partying in town. They gave me the address and invited me to join them after I returned to my hostel, showered and changed out of my wet clothes.

I fully intended to meet them.

I even drunkenly found something to eat before returning to Bambuda. However, once I had showered and climbed into bed, the room began spinning just enough to destroy my motivation.

Instead of continuing the party, I stayed exactly where I was and went to sleep.

Apparently, I was no longer 20.

Woman posing between two costumed pirate crew members aboard the Black Magic party boat in Bocas del Toro, Panama.

I had been looking forward to the Black Magic pirate cruise since arriving in Bocas. Naturally, I had to recruit the crew for a proper pirate photo once the rum punches started working.

Finding the Caribbean Beach I Came For

The morning after the pirate ship was considerably less painful than I had expected.

Going to bed instead of continuing the party had apparently been the correct decision. I wasn’t exactly bursting with energy, but I also wasn’t trapped beneath my dorm curtain questioning every rum punch I had consumed.

It was definitely a drink-a-lot-of-water kind of morning.

After Playa Istmito failed to deliver the scenery I had imagined, I was determined to find a proper beach. I took a local bus toward Bocas del Drago, then continued on foot along the coast to Starfish Beach.

The coastal walk gave me a chance to enjoy the island instead of being delivered directly to the beach. I could follow the water, stop whenever I wanted and slowly make my way toward the place I had been waiting to see.

Eventually, I reached Starfish Beach—and this time, Bocas del Toro looked exactly as I had hoped it would.

The water was calm, warm and clear enough to see the sea stars resting beneath the surface. They looked almost like colourful cushions scattered across the sandy bottom.

Despite the name of the beach, seeing them still felt special.

I stayed far enough away to avoid disturbing them and took my photographs from above the water. Sea stars are living animals, even when they appear completely motionless, and visitors should never lift them out of the water or handle them for a picture.

The day was hot, so I spent much of the afternoon moving between the beach and the sea. Whenever the heat became uncomfortable, I went back into the water. When I wanted a break, I returned to the sand and watched the boats arriving with other visitors.

Eventually, I ordered a late lunch—or possibly an early dinner—at one of the restaurants along the beach. Eating beside the water was the Caribbean experience I had been looking for.

I would have loved to stay for sunset, but I still needed to walk back along the coast and find transportation to Bocas Town. I was travelling without a phone and had no interest in navigating an unfamiliar path after dark.

As the afternoon began disappearing, I reluctantly retraced my steps toward the road.

My body may still have been recovering from the previous day, but I had finally found my tropical Caribbean beach.

Woman taking a selfie beside several sea stars resting underwater at Starfish Beach in Bocas del Toro, Panama.

Starfish Beach finally delivered the Caribbean experience I had been looking for. The sea stars were clearly visible through the shallow water—and remained exactly where they belonged.

Dolphins, White Sand and Finally Booking a Tour

For my final full day in Bocas del Toro, I finally decided to stop being lazy and book an organised boat tour.

Until then, I had mostly arranged my own adventures. However, many of the archipelago’s best places could only be reached by boat, and I didn’t want to leave without seeing more of the islands.

The first stop was Dolphin Cove.

The name had created certain expectations, and fortunately, the dolphins cooperated. We saw several swimming around the boat, occasionally surfacing long enough for everyone to point excitedly in their direction.

Wildlife never follows a tour schedule, so seeing so many dolphins felt even more special.

From there, we stopped at a floating restaurant to order lunch. Rather than sit around while the food was prepared, we continued toward Zapatilla Island.

The weather was overcast, but even without perfect blue skies, Zapatilla was gorgeous.

Soft white sand met clear water, and palm trees lined the shore. Playa Istmito had left me wondering where all the beautiful beaches were hiding.

Apparently, they were here.

While some people remained near where the boat had dropped us, I walked around the island. It was small enough to explore on foot, and following the shoreline allowed me to see more than the section immediately in front of the boats.

After exploring Zapatilla, we returned to the floating restaurant. By then, travelling between islands had made me hungry, and our meals were waiting for us.

Once everyone had eaten, it was time to get back into the water.

Our next stop was for snorkelling. Beneath the surface, I saw coral, fish, sea urchins and brittle stars. After spending so much of my trip exploring Central America on land, I loved being reminded that some of the most interesting scenery was underwater.

I floated above the reef, looking down at everything moving between the coral and trying to absorb as much as possible before we had to return to the boat.

Our final stop brought us back toward the area around Starfish Beach. This time, we didn’t dock. We remained on the water and looked for more sea stars beneath the surface.

By the time we returned to Bocas Town, the disappointment of my first afternoon had completely disappeared. The following morning, it would be time to begin the long journey back to Panama City.

One Last Boat Ride Back to the Mainland

The following morning, I packed my backpack and left Bambuda Bocas Town.

Getting back to Panama City meant reversing the journey that had brought me to the islands. I took a water taxi from Bocas Town to the mainland, then began the long bus journey across the country.

I don’t remember stopping anywhere overnight along the way. By that point, I had a list of things waiting for me in Panama City—and replacing my missing phone was near the top of it.

I had managed surprisingly well with my ancient iPod Touch, hostel Wi-Fi and information saved offline. It had helped me travel across western Panama and find my pirate-ship ticket while holding up an entire line, but I was ready to own a functioning phone again.

I also wanted to visit the Panama Canal and needed time to prepare for the final part of my route through the country. Rather than flying from Panama to Colombia, I had booked a multi-day journey by boat through the San Blas Islands.

Bocas del Toro had started with an underwhelming beach but ended up delivering everything I wanted from Panama’s Caribbean coast. I drank rum on a pirate ship, jumped into the sea, found a proper tropical beach, watched dolphins and snorkelled above coral filled with marine life.

Now it was time to return to Panama City, buy a new iPhone and prepare to leave Central America behind.

But Panama still had one final adventure waiting for me.

Next stop: the San Blas Islands.

Bocas del Toro gave me disappointing first impressions, rum-fuelled pirate adventures and the tropical beaches I had been searching for. Panama certainly knew how to make my final stop memorable.

Enjoyed this story? Toss a tip in the jar—thanks for reading.



Next
Next

How to File a Travel Insurance Claim Without Losing Your Mind